Home / Guides / When something goes wrong

Guide 06When something goes wrong

How to answer a procedural fairness letter

A procedural fairness letter is not a refusal. It’s the officer telling you what worries them before they decide. Here is what it means, how to work out your deadline, and how to write a response that answers the concern without making things worse.

Cross-checked 5 Oct 202610 references9 min readSources: canada.ca · Justice Laws

1 The concern · 2 The rule it relates to · 3 Your time limit · 4 How to send your reply. Real letters vary: read yours word for word.

The short answer

A procedural fairness letter means an IRCC officer has a concern that could lead to a refusal, and is telling you about it before deciding. It is not a refusal yet. It’s your chance to answer. Find the exact concern, answer it with an honest explanation and evidence, and send it before the deadline in your letter, the way the letter tells you to.

01 · What the letter is

The officer has to tell you before deciding against you

IRCC’s instructions to its own decision-makers say procedural fairness applies to every kind of immigration and citizenship application, at every stage. It means you get a fair and unbiased assessment, you are told the decision-maker’s concerns, and you get a real chance to respond to them.

That is why the letter exists. If an officer is leaning toward refusing you over something you haven’t had the chance to explain, they are supposed to tell you. This matters most when the concern comes from somewhere other than you, which IRCC calls extrinsic evidence: a check with your school, say, or information from one of IRCC’s partners. If the officer relies on it, they must tell you and let you respond.

The letter doesn’t have to include every document the officer looked at. What it must do is give you the essence of the concern and tell you which provision of the law is at issue.

What to find in your letter

Write down four things first: the concern, the rule it relates to, how much time you have, and how to send your reply. IRCC says its requests tell you what it needs, how to submit and how much time you have. The pins on the example letter above mark each one.

02 · Common concerns

What officers are usually worried about

These come from IRCC’s own instructions and pages. Yours may raise something else: what counts is its exact wording.

Possible misrepresentation

The officer thinks something important was false or left out. The most serious kind: read section 05.

A document couldn’t be verified

IRCC contacts issuers to confirm documents are genuine. When a study permit applicant’s letter of acceptance comes back “no match”, the officer offers procedural fairness and asks for a new one.

Information from someone else

Something IRCC learned from a third party or partner doesn’t match your application. You have the right to respond.

Is the relationship genuine?

For spouses and partners, the law excludes a relationship that isn’t genuine or was entered into primarily to gain status in Canada.

Something said at an interview

If new concerns come up at an interview, the officer should let you address them there or in a letter afterwards.

A specific requirement

The officer isn’t satisfied you meet a rule of your program. The letter should name that rule.

Whatever the concern, the decision must be based on the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and its Regulations, and IRCC’s letters should cite the provision. Looking it up tells you exactly what you need to show.

03 · Your deadline

Work out your date, then plan to beat it

Your letter sets your deadline, as a date or a number of days. Use what your letter says, not a number you’ve read online: letters differ. If it isn’t clear whether the days run from the date on the letter or the day you received it, count from the earlier date.

Your response plan

Enter the date on your letter and the days it gives you to see your deadline and a safer send-by date. Nothing you type leaves this page.

Add the number of days in your letter to the date it counts from, and mark that date on a calendar. Then plan to send your response a few days earlier, in case of technical problems. If your letter gives a date instead, that date is your deadline.

This adds calendar days. It’s a planning aid, not an official calculation: if your letter gives a date, that date wins.

Before you send it

04 · How to respond

How to respond, step by step

  1. Read the exact concern, twice

    Copy the sentence that states the concern into your notes and look up the provision the letter names. Your response should answer that, not re-argue your whole application.

  2. Gather evidence that answers it

    Choose documents that speak directly to the concern. If a document couldn’t be verified, give the officer something they can check, such as a letter from the issuer. A pile of unrelated papers only makes the answer harder to find.

  3. Write a clear, honest explanation

    Quote the concern, then answer it point by point, saying which document proves each point. Use plain facts and dates. If something in your application was wrong, say so and explain how it happened. Don’t guess, and don’t change your story.

  4. Add sworn statements if they help

    A signed statement from someone who knows the facts, such as an employer, can support your explanation, but it doesn’t replace official records. An affidavit is sworn before a notary public, commissioner of oaths or similar official. Translate anything not in English or French (see the note).

  5. Submit it the way the letter says

    IRCC says you must follow its instructions, or your application may be delayed. Some accounts take only one file per request (in the IRCC secure account, under 4 MB), so you may need to combine documents into one PDF.

  6. Keep proof

    Save a copy of everything you sent, plus the confirmation message or email from your account or the web form’s acknowledgement of receipt.

Where your response goes

ChannelUse it whenProof you sent it
Your IRCC accountThe letter tells you to use it. You can upload only where IRCC asked for something.Confirmation message and email
IRCC web formYou can’t submit in an account or any other way, or the letter points you to it.Acknowledgement of receipt
Email, mail or faxOnly when the letter gives you that contact information.Your sent email or a tracking receipt

Not sure what the officer means? IRCC says you can ask about its request through the web form, or by uploading a letter with your question in your account, if you were told to use it. Ask early.

05 · The misrepresentation risk

If the letter mentions misrepresentation, slow down

Look for the word misrepresentation or a reference to section 40 of the Act. A finding here doesn’t only end this application.

Section 40 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act makes a person inadmissible for directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of this Act.

That covers leaving out important facts, not just saying something false. The inadmissibility lasts five years, and during that time a foreign national can’t apply for permanent residence.

IRCC lists what can follow when false documents or information are sent: the application is refused, you could be banned from Canada for at least 5 years, you could have a permanent record of fraud with IRCC, your status or citizenship could be taken away, and you could be removed from Canada.

A representative who advises you to give false information is breaking the law, IRCC says, and if you give it, your application will be refused.

What this means for your response

  • Answer truthfully. The law already requires anyone who applies to answer truthfully and produce the relevant documents an officer reasonably requires.
  • Never answer a concern with a document you can’t fully stand behind.
  • If something was wrong or missing before, explain what happened, when, and why, with evidence.

With five years at stake, have this response checked before you send it. Get a licensed consultant or lawyer to review your response, and give them the full letter and everything you originally submitted.

06 · More time, or missed it

If you need more time, or the date has passed

Asking for more time

IRCC’s guidance on requested documents says you can ask for more time if you can’t get a document on time. You must explain why, and should include proof that you tried to get it. Send the request in your account where the document was requested (if you were told to use your account), by following the contact instructions in the letter, or through the web form.

Don’t treat a request as an automatic extension. Ask early, send what you have by the original deadline, and the rest the moment you get it.

If the deadline has passed

IRCC’s instructions protect the time you were given; nothing in them promises a late response will be considered. If you haven’t had a decision, send your response now, through the channel in your letter or the web form, with a sentence explaining why it’s late. If you’ve already been refused, read what to do after a refusal: some options have short deadlines of their own.

07 · Questions

Questions people ask

Is a procedural fairness letter a refusal?

No. The officer is giving you the chance to respond to a concern before deciding. What you send can change the outcome.

Can I see the evidence the officer is relying on?

Not necessarily. IRCC’s instructions say the officer doesn’t have to give you the actual documents they consulted, but must tell you the essence of the concern and the provision of the law at issue, and give you a reasonable opportunity to respond.

I got a second letter. Why?

One reason is that your file moved to a different officer. IRCC’s instructions say the person who decides must make their own assessment, so a new officer may need to send a new letter or interview you again.

I’ve been asked to an interview. Do I have to go?

Treat it as required. The Act says a person who applies must appear for an examination when an officer asks, and must answer questions truthfully. If you’re interviewed, IRCC’s instructions say you should be allowed to bring an interpreter, and in some cases one should be provided.

Do I need a consultant or lawyer to respond?

No, you can respond yourself. Paid help must be authorized, so check their licence first. For a misrepresentation letter, a professional review is worth it.

08 · Sources

Sources

  1. Procedural fairness, IRCC program delivery instructions, canada.ca (modified 2023-08-29)
  2. Submit new documents or information we requested, canada.ca (modified 2026-09-03)
  3. IRCC web form: Contact us online, canada.ca (modified 2026-06-01)
  4. Consequences of immigration and citizenship fraud, canada.ca (modified 2026-09-01)
  5. Is it legal to provide false information on my application, if a representative advises me to do so?, IRCC Help Centre (modified 2026-09-28)
  6. Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 40, Justice Laws Website (current to 2026-09-21)
  7. Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 16, Justice Laws Website (current to 2026-09-21)
  8. Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, section 4, Justice Laws Website (current to 2026-09-21)
  9. Express Entry: scan and upload documents (translations and affidavits), canada.ca (modified 2026-06-22)
  10. Fraud and compliance in the International Student Program, IRCC committee briefing, canada.ca (modified 2026-08-21)

Want a licensed consultant to look at your case?

Answer five short questions and see the licensed consultants who fit your situation, with the reasons why. Free, and nobody pays to rank higher.